The Audacity of Denial: notes on CNN’s Black (and Heterosexual) in America
Posted in Uncategorized on July 28th, 2008 by timmwestOkay. I’ve had a couple of days to let the piece settle. Many or most are aware of CNN’s recent two part special on Black (and Heterosexual) in America. It was advertised as Black in America, so I expected to see myself there….somewhere… and a few times I caught what might be a glimpse: identified with a young, curious kid who believed that incentives might be a way of “highering” motivation for academic achievement, sympathized with the single mother of 5 in Houston struggling to make ends make sense, even identified and was moved by the reunion of families, like so many of ours, who are cut off from white and/or Native cousins. To be sure, a four hour special on Black in America cannot cover everyone, but absolutely NO mention of LGBT African-Americans, even as a point of complexity that can be covered in a later exploration, is another huge slap in the face to Black LGBT America. I’m not sure who to be more upset with, LGBT Black America for its continuous complicit silence; for agreeing to be silent for the sake of not “stirring up trouble” with our feigned, “unified”, essentializing blackness…. OR CNN for having the audacity to completely omit it. But I should have expected what I saw. And so perhaps my own hopefulness is what I am most disappointed about.
Silence is more than deafening; like Audre Lorde suggested, it’s DEATH. In such instances where a “reliable news source” proposes to “tackle” the hard issues facing black America, we get the same patriarchal ham hock that continues to choke us, give us high blood pressure, if tasty and non-confrontational. We get whatever is reducible to what will appease black mega-churches on Sunday, forgetting that millions of black people aren’t there.
The face of AIDS in Black America, for example, while increasingly absorbing more African-American women, is the black gay man. A PWA (person with AIDS) I don’t hold any shame about the associations of black gay men and AIDS. The statistics are evidence enough of the shame we carry. Some suggest that if you mention gay men with AIDS that’s all that black people will think about us. Well, Newsflash: They ALREADY think that about us. So while I understand appreciation for the omission in that respect, it’s still shameful. As long as black gay men are dying of AIDS, it’s not a crisis in our community. Once heterosexual black women get it, we have a state of emergency. Tell me if that’s not downright differentiation of life-worth.
It’s not just the AIDS epidemic that could have been covered with regard to black gays. Beyond how it is believed that some 46 percent of black gay men in many cities are infected, LGBT black folk are also educators, single parent mothers and fathers, scholars, brothas behind bars, physicians… Oh… I suppose we could assume that any number of those interviewed for the special could have also been gay or lesbian (e.g., “speculative identification”…find yourself in the absences, like when reading history books)… but the silence of it reeks, not like dirty laundry, STANK laundry….the mildewed STANK of neglect when you know some nasty shit is in your house and you pretend it’s not there until neighbors and inspectors come to find, not some old food, but somebody dead under the house. Black gays and lesbians are somebody dead under the house– often suffocated by our own hesitance and shame… and it’s time that we raise the muthafuckin dead! Enough with trying to be nice about this stuff.
I shouldn’t come off as completely negative. I’m sure that many white people learned a lot of “new” things about Obama’s people; and maybe even themselves (e.g., “white people suffer too”). There were various truths uncovered– if the echoing painful statistics that most conscious black Americans already knew about. Like many black specials, you’re left feeling hopeless, as if given a mirror so that you can verify your own disfigurement. I’m not sure where the hopefulness was, but I had to find it beyond the showcase.
This isn’t just another “Why didn’t they expose the gays at the family reunion, or jails, or the gay rap artists” vent. Representation, when not done with earnest and respectful intentions, comes off as condescending and tokenizing at best. Still, could we have gotten a line or two in relationship to the minister who doesn’t do enough to address AIDS in his black church? The homos were surely there, stifled by his awkward silence, suffocating underneath the church pews in the silence. Could we not talk about how many black gay men ARE raising their children (by blood or adoption) in spite of a political climate hostile to gay parenting against the logic that too many black children need loving, nurturing guidance? Can we talk about the ridiculousness of encouraging black women to marry their “baby daddies” when many of these “conceptions” were the result of one-night standing or irresponsible sexual slips? Can we discuss how many mothers, albeit alone, raised strong, self-reliant, productive black men who are an asset to the “community”? Can we talk about breast cancer? Can we talk to women who aren’t, in fact, traumatized that they can’t find a black man…or who don’t want one at all? Can we talk about black artists, or is everyone chasing the dollar and a home in suburbia? Damn! Is anybody else feeling me?
I think I’ve come to a conclusion watching the CNN special. We have a divided black America. Some people didn’t see it and wouldn’t care to see anything about the “state of Black America”. Others saw it and became upset, incensed, and sensitized to the plight of many their brothas and sistahs who have largely been forgotten. Some watched it and said…”I gots mine, my brotha, You, gots to get your own”. And there are those, like me– not even just gay blacks, but progressive blacks– who were utterly disgusted by the patronizing, glossy, exposition about the continuing decline of half our race while the others of us Americanize and forget. A black man, as portrayed by CNN, is either a thug OR someone anxious about ways to dis-identify with black culture and experience. Save Dyson, I didn’t see a reflection myself anywhere in those four hours. They didn’t even talk about Dyson’s anti-homophobia stance. Strong black heterosexual men are, of course, homophobic, right?
Do I ever expect to see a more accurate reflection of my black experience in America? Not until we (LBGT Negroes) seize the blogs and the airwaves, make more black gay music, write more black gay revolutionary poems, have more black gay affirming sermons and shame the ministers who try to shame us, have our families look at us, mouths wide open and often aghast, for having resurrected our truth and placed it alive and center to the black experience. We need more black gay families and parents and people in relationships to come out of their closets. A closet ignored becomes a grave. I am not dead, America. The audacity of my truth speaks, if romantically or revolutionary at times, against any portrayal that continues to bury my experience, contributions, and possibility. And I don’t plan to shut up about it until I see a reflection of, not just my own experience, but all those deadened through the silence of authoritative journalism. Shame Shame Shame on the Cowardly Normalization Network’s peek into “Black (and Heterosexual) in America”. We won’t see any different until we who are cast out and told to shut up for peace sake gain courage enough to represent ourselves…the way we REALLY are… and hold people accountable for such cowardly omissions.
Next?
